Do Not Sell My Personal Information
RugbyDump RugbyDump
Sunday Feb 10, 2019

Should Peter O'Mahony's challenge on Stuart Hogg have gone unpunished?

Should Peter O'Mahony's challenge on Stuart Hogg have gone unpunished?

As Ireland recorded their first victory of this year’s 6 Nations campaign away to Scotland this weekend, Peter O’Mahony may well be counting his lucky stars after an alleged late challenge on Scotland full-back Stuart Hogg.

Hogg injured his shoulder in the incident and was forced off shortly afterwards, denting the home side’s chances of competing in a bruising encounter.

The pain was doubly hard on the Scots as they gifted Conor Murray an easy try after a defensive mix-up between Tommy Seymour and Sean Maitland. Ireland eventually came out on top 22-13 to keep their championship hopes alive.

O’Mahony was busy defending the outside channel when Hogg began his counter-attack. Hogg then chipped over the top, with O’Mahony not moving out of the way in time.

The incident was not reviewed by the TMO, but it was a topic of debate with the BBC Sport team at half-time, with pundit and former Scotland captain believing that it was “late” but that he “wasn’t sure it was a penalty, but that was where his injury came in.”

Scotland head coach Gregor Townsend refused to be drawn into a debate as to whether O’Mahony should have been penalised, but instead bemoaned the loss of his star player Hogg.

“It’s disappointing, he chipped ahead and he was sandwiched between two players…there was a collision there that forced him to fly over and land on the point of his shoulder. It was a big moment in the game because we conceded the try a minute after that,” Townsend said.

“When the referee goes back [to the TMO] it tends to be if a try has been scored straight away or if the TMO is watching the incident in slow motion, it’s hard to keep an eye on it all the time because the game is so quick.”

O’Mahony did appear to be on his way down anyway, but whether the back-rower could have made more of an effort to stay out of Hogg’s way remains unclear. In any case, it is unlikely that this incident would have had much bearing on the game, with Ireland a vastly different side to the one which was defeated by England in Dublin last weekend.

Ireland themselves lost talisman Jonny Sexton in the opening half as well, after being put firmy through the ringer by the Scottish defence. Claims that Sexton was targeted again perhaps had some grounding, due to the out-half being put to deck by the likes of Jamie Ritchie, Ryan Wilson and Stuart McInally.

But claims Joe Schmidt appeared to accuse a Scottish player of stamping on Sexton’s head – prior to the Leinster man failing an HIA test – were quickly debunked by the coach himself.

“[Jonny] copped a stamp, but I don’t think it was a Scottish player. I think it was actually one of our guys who tripped up over him at the ruck,” Schmidt said afterwards.


  • danknapp
    8:05 PM 10/02/2019
    Top Comment

    You know what should be given a ban? Inverdale's leggings. They can return to the depths of hell.No middle-aged man should ever wear trousers so tight-fitting. That's a straight red in my book.

  • davidb
    6:48 PM 10/02/2019

    Re the hit on Hogg I don't understand why you don't see the offence from the video.  Rory Best is not relevant.  The issue of foul play is not the sandwiching of Hogg.  Best does cut across Hogg a little but you could argue he's just running his line.  However Mahoney clearly and deliberately moves to his right to impede Hogg, then he clearly drops his forearm in order to lift his elbow and use it to hit Hogg.  To me it's clear and obvious..  The play was then continuous until the Irish try.  There would have been no try had the correct decision of a penalty to Scotland been awarded.  I can maybe forgive the referee not seeing the incident but the linesman should have and the noise from the crowd should also have alerted them and the TMO to have a look at the contact.  What worries me is the combination of refereee, linesman and TMO all missing what was clearly an offence and in my view a yellow card offence.  I suspect Ireland would still have won as they were the better team overall but we might have had a more exciting second half game.

    • jmdavies
      9:54 AM 11/02/2019

      Completely agree, had O'Mahony remotely attempted an arm wrap i may have been more sympathetic to a maybe a little late call, but committed. As it was, shoulder charge to take Hogg out of the play. Dirty Hit

      • brianrutherford
        11:20 PM 12/03/2019

        Completely agree, O'Mahony deliberate late, and dangerous no arms tackle on Stuart Hogg, with assistance from Best which made Hogg land on his shoulder. Scotland were playing well at this point and Ireland were struggling. This piece of dirty play cost Scotland the match. How did they get away with it. The crowd screamed, linesman, ref and TMO did nothing.


Great Tries

View All

Big Hits & Dirty Play

View All

See It To Believe It

View All


View All


View All

Player Features

View All
Should Peter O'Mahony's challenge on Stuart Hogg have gone unpunished? | RugbyDump - Rugby News & Videos